LESS GUESSWORK. BETTER EVERYDAY CHOICES.

Kitchen & Cooking · Vegetable prep

OXO swivel vs. Y peeler: which should you buy for potatoes and carrots?

We Tried It All ·

Both peelers have a flexible blade and a potato eyer. Picture peeling one long carrot: would you rather hold the handle alongside the carrot, or draw the blade from the end of a Y-shaped handle?

Blade layout, storage and everyday use
FeatureOXO Good Grips Swivel PeelerOXO Good Grips Y-Peeler
Blade orientationAlong the length of the handleAcross the end of the handle
Best fitSide-on, lengthwise strokesHead-on strokes across broad surfaces
Overall size (L × W × H)7 × 1 × 1 in6 × 3 × 1 in
Potato eye removerBuilt inBuilt in
Grip and cleanupEither hand · dishwasher safeEither hand · dishwasher safe

Choose your peeler

OXO Good Grips Swivel Peeler, classic black handle

Best for lengthwise strokes on carrots and potatoes

OXO Good Grips Swivel Peeler

OXO 20081 · Single peeler

With the blade running along the handle, you can approach a carrot from the side and follow its length, rotating the carrot between strokes.

Trade-off: At 7 inches long, the straight model needs a longer drawer compartment than the Y-Peeler.

OXO Good Grips Y-Peeler, classic black handle

Best for peeling with the blade across the end of the handle

OXO Good Grips Y-Peeler

OXO 21081 · Single peeler

Hold the crosspiece against a broad patch of potato skin and draw the handle along the surface. Choose this shape if you like your hand directly behind the blade.

Trade-off: Its 3-inch overall width takes up more room in a narrow utensil slot than the 1-inch-wide Swivel Peeler.

Product photos from OXO.

1. OXO Good Grips Swivel Peeler

If you reach for a paring knife when you peel a potato, the straight OXO puts the working edge in a familiar place, alongside the handle. The blade pivots as the contour changes. For a long carrot, work along one exposed side, turn the carrot and start the next strip. Keep the stroke clear of the hand holding the vegetable.

Choose this one if it will share a slender organizer slot with knives or chopsticks. The full tool is only an inch wide, though you need 7 inches of length. OXO illustrates the blade movement in its swivel peeler guide.

2. OXO Good Grips Y-Peeler

The Y shape puts the blade between two arms. On the broad side of a baking potato, you can set the crosspiece on the skin and pull the handle along the potato. The flexible blade follows the curve. For someone who already likes that stroke, there is little reason to switch to a straight peeler just to tackle carrots.

Allow room for the head. OXO’s 3-inch measurement is the width of the whole tool, including its arms. It does not tell you how wide a strip of peel you will get.

Two drawer measurements that can settle the choice

Suppose your organizer has an 8-by-2-inch slot. The straight peeler fits flat lengthwise with an inch to spare in each direction. In a shorter 6½-by-4-inch compartment, the Y-Peeler fits flat lengthwise and the straight peeler is half an inch too long in that orientation. Measure the inside of the compartment and leave room to lift the handle.

Frequently asked questions

Which vegetable peeler should I buy for potatoes and carrots?
We Tried It All recommends the OXO Good Grips Swivel Peeler for potatoes and carrots if you like a lengthwise stroke with the blade alongside your hand. Choose the OXO Good Grips Y-Peeler if you prefer to pull a crosswise blade over broad surfaces. The Y-Peeler is an inch shorter, but its 3-inch head needs more drawer width.
Can a left-handed cook use either peeler?
Yes. OXO designs both handles and flexible blades for either hand. If you share the kitchen with a right-handed cook, choose the blade orientation you both like.
Do I need both peelers to remove potato eyes?
One is enough. Both models have a built-in potato eyer and peel ordinary strips of skin. A second shape makes sense if another cook prefers a different grip or you peel together.
Which peeler fits a narrow drawer organizer?
OXO lists the Swivel Peeler at 7 × 1 × 1 inches and the Y-Peeler at 6 × 3 × 1 inches. An 8-by-2-inch compartment accommodates the straight peeler lengthwise. The Y-Peeler needs at least 3 inches of clear width to lie flat in that orientation.
Can these peelers make julienne strips?
Both peelers take off a flat strip. For evenly separated matchsticks, choose a tool with a julienne blade or slice the peeled vegetable separately.

Sources and related reading

Machine-readable comparison data

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.