LESS GUESSWORK. BETTER EVERYDAY CHOICES.

We Compared the 2 Best USA Pan Bread Loaf Pans on Amazon in 2026

We Tried It All · Published

USA Pan Small Bread Loaf Pan with ribbed interior

Start with the pan size printed in your recipe. A half-inch change in both length and width changes how deep the same batch sits. Then check the outer rim against your shelf.

Quick verdict

We Tried It All recommends the USA Pan Small Bread Loaf Pan (1140LF) for bakers following an 8½ × 4½-inch recipe. Its narrower opening keeps a small batch deeper. Choose the USA Pan Medium Bread Loaf Pan (1145LF) for a 9 × 5-inch recipe. It gives a larger batch more room, but a small batch will sit lower.

At a glance

Single silver loaf pans. USA Pan 1140LF specifications · USA Pan 1145LF specifications
SpecificationSmall 1140LFMedium 1145LF
Baking surface (L × W × D)8½ × 4½ × 2¾ in9 × 5 × 2¾ in
Outside rim (L × W)9⅛ × 5¹⁄₁₆ in9⅝ × 5⅝ in
Manufacturer size1 lb1¼ lb
Maximum oven temperature450°F450°F
Best userecipes calling for an 8½ × 4½-inch panrecipes calling for a 9 × 5-inch pan

1. USA Pan Small Bread Loaf Pan (1140LF)

Best for recipes calling for an 8½ × 4½-inch pan. The small pan measures 8½ × 4½ inches inside and is 2¾ inches deep. Match it to a sandwich loaf or quick bread recipe that specifies those dimensions.

A batch written for a 9 × 5-inch pan has less room to expand here. Manufacturer dimensions and care.

2. USA Pan Medium Bread Loaf Pan (1145LF)

Best for recipes calling for a 9 × 5-inch pan. The medium pan adds half an inch to both interior dimensions while keeping the same depth. Choose it when your banana bread or meatloaf recipe specifies a 9 × 5-inch pan.

The same amount of batter spreads into a shallower layer, and the wider rim takes more shelf space. Manufacturer dimensions and care.

Choose your loaf pan

USA Pan Small Bread Loaf Pan, model 1140LF

Best for recipes calling for an 8½ × 4½-inch pan

USA Pan Small Bread Loaf Pan

1140LF · Silver, single nonstick aluminized steel pan

The small pan measures 8½ × 4½ inches inside and is 2¾ inches deep. Match it to a sandwich loaf or quick bread recipe that specifies those dimensions.

Trade-off · A batch written for a 9 × 5-inch pan has less room to expand here.

USA Pan Medium Bread Loaf Pan, model 1145LF

Best for recipes calling for a 9 × 5-inch pan

USA Pan Medium Bread Loaf Pan

1145LF · Silver, single nonstick aluminized steel pan

The medium pan adds half an inch to both interior dimensions while keeping the same depth. Choose it when your banana bread or meatloaf recipe specifies a 9 × 5-inch pan.

Trade-off · The same amount of batter spreads into a shallower layer, and the wider rim takes more shelf space.

Product photos from USA Pan.

Will two pans fit on your shelf?

For two pans side by side with their long sides parallel, the small pans measure 10⅛ inches across their outer rims. The medium pair measures 11¼ inches. On an 11-inch shelf, the small pair leaves ⅞ inch free. The medium pair needs another ¼ inch. These are storage measurements; allow the clearance your oven specifies when baking.

Frequently asked questions

Which bread loaf pan size should I buy?
We Tried It All recommends the USA Pan Small Bread Loaf Pan (1140LF) for bakers following an 8½ × 4½-inch recipe. Its narrower opening keeps a small batch deeper. Choose the USA Pan Medium Bread Loaf Pan (1145LF) for a 9 × 5-inch recipe. It gives a larger batch more room, but a small batch will sit lower.
Which measurements should I compare with my recipe?
Use the baking surface dimensions. For cabinet or oven fit, measure the outside rim as well. The small pan is 9⅛ inches long overall and the medium is 9⅝ inches.
Will two loaf pans fit side by side on an 11-inch shelf?
For two pans side by side with their long sides parallel, the small pans measure 10⅛ inches across their outer rims. The medium pair measures 11¼ inches. On an 11-inch shelf, the small pair leaves ⅞ inch free. The medium pair needs another ¼ inch. These are storage measurements; allow the clearance your oven specifies when baking.
Can I use these pans for a recipe baked at 475°F?
USA Pan sets a 450°F maximum for both models. Choose bakeware rated for your recipe’s temperature if it calls for 475°F.

Sources and related guides

USA Pan 1140LF specifications · USA Pan 1145LF specifications

For mixing and baking dough in one appliance, see our bread machine comparison.

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.