LESS GUESSWORK. BETTER EVERYDAY CHOICES.

We Compared the 2 Best Lodge Cast Iron Skillets on Amazon in 2026

We Tried It All · Published

Lodge 10.25-Inch Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet with assist handle and pour spouts

The number on a Lodge skillet describes its nominal size. Two other measurements can settle the choice before you buy: the flat bottom where your food sits and the distance from one handle tip to the other.

Quick verdict

We Tried It All recommends the Lodge 10.25-Inch Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet (L8SK3) for everyday cooking in a smaller kitchen. It weighs 5.66 lb and spans 16.12 inches including the handles. Choose the Lodge 12-Inch Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet (L10SK3) for a wider, 9.12-inch flat bottom when cooking in one layer. It adds 2.03 lb and needs 18 inches of shelf length.

At a glance

Classic seasoned cast iron skillets, single-pan versions. Lodge L8SK3 specifications · Lodge L10SK3 specifications
Measurement10.25-inch L8SK312-inch L10SK3
Flat-bottom width8 in9.12 in
Length including handles16.12 in18 in
Outside width10.68 in12.56 in
Empty weight5.66 lb7.69 lb
Height2 in2.25 in
Best useDaily cooking with limited storageWide portions in one layer

1. Lodge 10.25-Inch Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet (L8SK3)

Best for daily cooking in a smaller kitchen. For a typical breakfast, trace an 8-inch circle on paper and lay your usual slices of bread inside it. If they fit comfortably, the smaller skillet gives you the flat space you need and saves weight each time you move it from stove to sink.

Larger pieces of food can reach the sloped sides sooner. Lodge L8SK3 specifications.

2. Lodge 12-Inch Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet (L10SK3)

Best for larger portions in a single layer. If a tortilla measures 9 inches across, the larger skillet’s 9.12-inch flat bottom gives it space to lie flat on paper. In the smaller pan it would extend up the sides. That difference matters more for a flatbread than for a scramble you can stir.

At 7.69 lb empty, it weighs 2.03 lb more before dinner goes in. Lodge L10SK3 specifications.

Choose your skillet

Lodge 10.25-Inch Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet, model L8SK3

Best for daily cooking in a smaller kitchen

Lodge 10.25-Inch Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet

L8SK3 · Classic black single skillet with assist handle

An 8-inch flat bottom and a 16.12-inch overall length suit smaller portions and shorter shelves.

Trade-off · Larger pieces of food can reach the sloped sides sooner.

Lodge 12-Inch Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet, model L10SK3

Best for larger portions in a single layer

Lodge 12-Inch Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet

L10SK3 · Classic black single skillet with assist handle

The 9.12-inch flat bottom gives wide pieces of food more room to sit flat.

Trade-off · At 7.69 lb empty, it weighs 2.03 lb more before dinner goes in.

Product photos from Lodge Cast Iron.

Measure the shelf with the handle in mind

Suppose your cabinet has 17 inches of usable depth. Stored with the long handle pointing straight back, the smaller skillet leaves 0.88 inch to spare. The larger skillet extends an inch beyond the opening. If you can turn the handle sideways, measure the clear width and the door opening before ruling it out.

Frequently asked questions

Which Lodge cast iron skillet size should I buy?
We Tried It All recommends the Lodge 10.25-Inch Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet (L8SK3) for everyday cooking in a smaller kitchen. It weighs 5.66 lb and spans 16.12 inches including the handles. Choose the Lodge 12-Inch Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet (L10SK3) for a wider, 9.12-inch flat bottom when cooking in one layer. It adds 2.03 lb and needs 18 inches of shelf length.
How much extra flat space does the 12-inch skillet give me?
Lodge lists flat-bottom widths of 8 and 9.12 inches. Treating each as a circle gives roughly 50 and 65 square inches respectively. That is about 30% more flat area, though the shape of your food determines what actually fits.
Will either skillet fit in a cabinet 17 inches deep?
Suppose your cabinet has 17 inches of usable depth. Stored with the long handle pointing straight back, the smaller skillet leaves 0.88 inch to spare. The larger skillet extends an inch beyond the opening. If you can turn the handle sideways, measure the clear width and the door opening before ruling it out.
Which skillet is easier to lift into the oven?
The 10.25-inch skillet weighs 5.66 lb empty, compared with 7.69 lb for the 12-inch. If lifting a filled pan is the deciding factor, choose the smaller one. Both have an assist handle opposite the long handle.
Does the larger size change how I clean it?
Lodge gives the same care instructions for both sizes. Hand wash the skillet, dry it, then apply a light coat of oil. The larger model takes up more sink space.

Sources and related guides

For cooking with a lid and higher sides, see our enameled Dutch oven comparison.

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.